Start a new topic

Find and Find/Replace - In need of modernizing

I think it's high time someone spoke up about DbVisualizer's handling of Find and Find/Replace.



Firstly:  FIND

This functionality is in desperate need of upgrade.  I mean, when one presses CTRL+F they're presented with the older-than-a-decade yellow text box?  No help?  No dialog?  Nothing.  Then, they're expected to just know to press F3 to get "next result".


With respect to the FIND WITH DIALOG feature, much better.  Much closer.  If nothing else, this should definitely be the default.  But even then some attention would seem necessary.  If one selects "GLOBAL" why does the "DIRECTION" still apply?  I must be dense but I honestly don't know what "ORIGIN" is all about; "TARGET" is enough for me.



Secondly:  FIND/REPLACE

The FIND/REPLACE feature only has a dialog.  Cool.  That's a better place to start with.  But the execute command reads "FIND".  Then, the dialog closes and users are presented with options:  Replace, Skip, All, Cancel.  What!?  It's just so abnormally and unfamiliar.  It works, I'll give you that but it's not normal.  It confuses folks.  Why not just offer those options in the same dialog without having to hit "FIND" first.  After all, I wasn't trying to FIND anything... I was trying to REPLACE text.  It's counter intuitive to have to hit FIND before being prompted to do something with it.



How could it be better?

I think Excel has got to be my personal favorite FIND and FIND/REPLACE dialog.  It's ever so clear.  Options, when desired, are easily provided but given a backseat to default settings.  It's movable around the screen.  Text is clear.  It's just easy.


Also, for anyone else that might agree with me... I long ago swapped my CTRL+F hotkey from "FIND" to "Find with Dialog" which, while not perfect, is much closer to what I'd expect.



Final thoughts

Honestly, for as much as I love this tool my team has complained about DbVisualizer's FIND and FIND/REPLACE functionality probably more than anything else.  With some love I'm sure this age-old standard functionality could be improved for modern expectations.


You rock!  Thanks for considering so thoughtfully.

Mike,


I completely agree with your observations. The find and find/replace functionality is part of the 3:rd editor component that DbVisualizer use and there are definitely room for improvements.


I'll open a ticket and we will discuss this.


Regards


Roger

Login or Signup to post a comment